A bit of a flashback for me, this is something I wrote ten years ago for an earlier blog, but I haven't yet shared it here.
In the Right Place for the Wrong Reasons
In an interview about The Lord of the Rings movie trilogy, Miranda Otto (Eowyn) said that we live in "cynical times", but that this is not a cynical movie. It shows goodness, truth, fellowship, and trust prevailing over darkness and betrayal. Those that fight against the darkness are often ordinary people thrust into extraordinary situations; they are not the fastest or strongest or bravest, yet they accept the call when it comes.
I believe we can be the white light in that cynical world, refusing to believe that truth and goodness cannot triumph. To paraphrase the king at the final battle, there may come a time when we will fail, where we will toss aside our bonds of fellowship, but it is not today! Yet we stumble and fall. We make mistakes.
Eowyn cannot. She wants to fight. Even though she is afraid, come the battle, she still wants to fight for her friends.
How many times do we know what we must do, but something calls us elsewhere? How many times, for good or bad, do we feel like we're abandoning our duty. Perhaps it's to do something we feel is greater. Often, it's simply out of apathy or fear. We turn away from what we should do and go elsewhere.
God is not as shallow as we. He sees possibility even where we see only weakness.
Eowyn turns away from her assigned duty; she goes to battle against her father's wishes. She risks not only her life, but Merry's, and those of the people she would leave behind should both their leaders die in battle.
Yet, God uses even this seeming mistake. At the pinnacle of the battle waits the Witch King, the Lord of the Nazgul and a creature that "no living man can kill". And there they are placed, through deceit, through abnegation of her duties, through spills and mistakes: Eowyn and Merry, a woman and a hobbit. There they are, among thousands of living men, mere yards from the Witch King, are the two people capable of destroying him.
Even through our pride, our desires, and our apparent mistakes, God can bring good. Had Eowyn not ridden out to that battle, had she not brought Merry with her, had they both not been there at that moment, Evil would have triumphed.